Search
Loading..
Subscribe to the Podcast and Blog
No RSS feeds have been linked to this section.
Ads
Twitter
Affiliate Links

 

Navigation
« Review: Hanasaku Iroha | Main | Winter Preview 2012, Part 2 »
Wednesday
Feb152012

Review: Steins;gate

15903-620x-2f25f7c955ebe3bca596b93ac8c00dbe.jpeg

There are few things in the world I enjoy more than I good time travel story. Time travel offers a unique twist to a standard narrative, in that, events don't always occur linearly. The events the characters experience are jumbled and due to this the plotting of a time travel story come out far more interesting than a standard drama. Steins;Gate takes place in Akihabara where a group of friends modified a microwave to send text messages into the past. Underestimating the consequences Okabe Rintaro, self proclaimed mad scientist, allows people to use the machine to change the past. What he discovers is that even altering the past slightly can completely change the world.

573830.jpgSteins;Gate is really two different shows. The first half is a Moe show with time travel elements and the second half is a time travel show with Moe elements. Strangely both work, for different reasons, and the transition from the lighthearted and fun atmosphere of the first half of the narrative moves smoothly when Steins;Gate suddenly becomes deadly serious. Such a change in tone is difficult to pull off, yet Steins;Gate manages it by having a fantastic first episode which encapsulates most of the elements that the series will represent going forward. The audience gets the insane antics of Okabe, the wonderful Moe of Mayuri, some of the deep time travel elements, technobabble, and murder. This execution is viewed in hindsight, however, as the first episode’s tonal imbalance may turn away overwhelmed viewers.

The element that really drew me into Steins;Gate was the use of internet culture as a hook, specifically using John Titor as the jumping point for the series. In late November 2000 a man who claimed to be a time traveler appeared on IRC and his claims have been immortalized on the internet. Steins;Gate's hook is when Okabe notices that the first message they send back in time, accidentally, erases John Titor from existence. Going forward Steins;Gate uses pieces of the John Titor story has important plot points including the search for the IBM 5100, Titor’s explanation of how time travel works, and the year John Titor claimed to have been from; 2036. Prior knowledge of John Titor isn't required to enjoy the narrative but you get a little extra out of the show by recognizing the references.

steins-gate-review-04.jpeg

Early in the show Okabe recruits Kurisu Makise, a prodigy scientist, and together they develop and test the Phone Microwave and it’s unique ability to send messages back in time, called "D-mail." Much of the first half of the show is spent on these experiments and on playing around with the show’s moe cast of characters. Being Akihabara, many of the characters are Otaku with classic Otaku tropes. Daru is a brilliant engineer but comes off as a lonely pervert, Mayuri is an adorable cosplay Otaku who works at a costume cafe, Feyris works with Mayuri and remains in her cat persona even outside of work, and various other characters. They're enjoyable to watch interact and the characters who get a chance to change the world with D-Mail get backstories which crush the heart of the viewer and Okabe in the same fatal stroke. However, I never felt like the majority of the characters received any depth. Most of them simply work as plot devices to drive the narrative forward, provide a reason to alter the course of the world. Even when their backstories were explored I felt more for Okabe than I did for the individual characters because he had to explain that their wishes were harming the course of time, and he felt responsible for them having to undo their changes to the past.

555913.jpeg

Kurisu Makise is also an interesting character. While she holds many of the stereotypical Tsundere traits she is given enough development to not only to overcome them but to somewhat justify them. Her secret obsession with 2channel gives her an interesting quark and the unintentional rivalry with her father both shows why she seems profoundly sad yet has accomplished so much at a young age. Even her first encounter with Okabe showed her range, at first she took a profound enjoyment out of proving him wrong and yet when he proved that time travel was possible she was humble enough to agree to work for him. I have a respect for characters who command respect and yet can be humble when they’re defeated. Mayuri offers an interesting intersect because while she is a character who exists as a plot device and doesn't have much development you can't help but fall in love with her. She is the sweetest, most gentle creature in the world, which works as a nice foil to the often abrasive and rude Okabe. She's able to bring out a side of Okabe no one else sees which makes their relationship profoundly endearing.

Time travel is the main focus of the plot in Steins;Gate. D-Mails sent into the past don't exactly change the future but shift the "world line" Okabe inhabits. He has the unique ability, conveniently, to remember all the world lines he happened to inhabit. His friends don't notice any change because they've always existed in the world created by the D-Mail. So "Time Travel" for the majority of Steins;Gate is actually "world line travel." Altering a small part of the past allows Okabe to jump between the world lines. Although later in the show more actual time travel takes place I enjoyed the plots created by the D-mails because of the mystery around what effect the message would have on Okabe's world. One simple jump and an element he was relaying on, a driving focus of the plot for the early episodes, would just disappear forcing Okabe to completely rethink his strategy. In total, Steins;Gate uses three methods of Time travel; world line travel, consciousness travel where a person's present mind jumps back into their physical body; and physical time travel where a character travels from the present into the past. Each of the methods are pulled off well with their own benefits and drawbacks expertly explored.

UTW-Mazui_SteinsGate_-_01_720p2994A18E.mkv_snapshot_09.56_2011.04.08_22.jpeg

One aspect of Steins;Gate that I didn't like is that the science changed when it became convenient to the characters. At one point Kurisu declares that her field of study was in the brain when she is first scene giving a presentation on physics and had, up to that point, only mentioned being a physicist. Another bit of rule breaking that irked me was they changed rules when the plot needed a rule to be changed. At first one Time Machine is limited to only travel backwards through time, which creates a depressing departure that the show spends an entire episode fixated on. Later a time machine of the same make has the ability to travel forwards and backwards through time, which gives Okabe an extra chance to change the past. It's sloppy storytelling and bad science fiction.

I've discussed how well I think the time travel elements of Steins;Gate work, and indeed at its core this is an extremely solid Time Travel narrative. However, the moe elements are going to drive away people who would otherwise find the series enjoyable. The early episodes are light on the Sci-fi and heavy on moe characters doing moe things, the pacing is slow allowing the audience to spend more time with the characters. Each episode reveals one small piece of the plot. When that shift in the middle of the series happens Steins;Gate becomes a serious time travel narrative but getting there is going to prove difficult for someone looking for good science fiction right from the start. It's unfortunate that by playing to the Otaku crowd who love both science fiction and moe, the audience who would most appreciate Steins;Gate won't be able to make it through those first few episodes.

520092.jpg

This review might feel a little negative but I can't stress enough how much I enjoyed Steins;Gate. For all it's failings, Okabe and Kurisu remain interesting characters and the way it employs the standard time travel tropes are always fun and entertaining. The dark, serious tone during the second half of the show is contains some incredible character drama despite the cast of mostly shallow characters. Okabe is forced to carry the burden of the narrative, being remembers world line jumps, that the depth of his character, what he goes through, and how he is profoundly changed by the end is truly moving. So while moe elements hold the show back and some of the science fiction elements are weak, the show comes off as a definite watch for science fiction and moe fans alike. No where near a perfect show, but an entertaining and moving piece of animation.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (3)

The John Titor reference and the talk of world lines in the very first episode are what initially piqued my interest. Even though it was mocked at first, it turned out to be mostly applicable to how sci-fi time travel worked in the show. It wasn't a perfect and infallible system, as you made apparent, but it was passable.

I enjoyed the silliness of the first half of the series or so and found myself a complete fan when the major plot twists began happening a little over halfway through. It was a bit awkward, but definitely one of my all-time favorites (my personal favorite of 2011).

El. Psy. Congroo.

February 15, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterStation-OX11

I agree the show took a bit to start and was pretty moe. I want to show this show to my family, they are not anime fans, but are huge sci-fi fans, and the sci-fi is good in this show. I'm afraid they won't get all the moe and tsundere type stuff.

Though I must disagree on the sloppy science fiction. As for Kirisu majoring in neuroscience, I agree came out of nowhere, but I didn't give it much thought. She's supposed to be a genius, so I figured it was one of her many degrees or something like that. As for the time machine being able to move forward as well as back it was obvious that Okabe was surprised as us at that. I figure the first time it was either so damaged it could only go back, even after Daru fixed it. Or that it's from a completely different world line so that the future Okabe and Daru had more time or were better equipped to make sure it went both ways.

In the world of science "Impossible" means "not yet." It was impossible the world was round, it was impossible to go to the moon, it was impossible to have color TV. It was once thought if the body went over 50mph it would simply explode. So especially in sci-fi shows when they say something is impossible I don't give it much credit.

March 2, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterKyle

Frankly, I think it makes a lot of sense that the time machine in the Alpha world line was able to travel both forward and backward, whereas the one in the Beta line couldn't.

In the Beta line, SERN kept the existence of time machines a secret from the world for a very long time (and thus they accrued power sans trouble). They were the only ones to be able to travel the timelines, and both Kurisu and Okabe were dead.

In the Alpha worldline, however, there was an international time machine arms race, so there were far more minds pushing the technology. Moreover, both Okabe and Kurisu, the pioneers of time travel, are alive and thus are able to share their expertise with the world.

In the Steins;Gate worldline, time machines don't exist. Okabe ensured that Kurisu's research burned in the plane accident, and she obviously has no intention of rewriting it.

May 26, 2012 | Unregistered Commenter13ack.Stab

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>